A Route With a Way Back
The Broken StandardIntermediateAbout 7–12 minutes of play
Choose an approach to Direfang Caves from a small set of evidence, including a safe place to regroup.
- Given by
- Sir Roderick
- Starts at
- Camp
- Place in the story
- Main story
- To start
- either The Weight of Good Iron finished or The Return Ration finished and
Defence 30 - To finish
Defence 30- Suggested levels
Defence 35
Walkthrough
A part only moves on when you press Continue or Turn in, and the quest pays out when you press Claim. Work done before a part begins never counts towards it.
Part 1: Read the council notes
Roderick supplies the same complete route notes after either preparation approach. No unseen branch information is needed.
- Inspect at Camp: Three approaches
Ford: short, but the return load exceeds its posted carrying limit. Gully: concealed, but its only exit is the entrance and there is no dry store. Ridge: longer, with a dry sheltered ledge before the cave approach. The council requires a route that can carry the return load and preserve a separate dry reserve.
Part 2: Select and sequence the plan
Choose the route that meets the stated constraints, then put scouting, reserve, advance and return in order.
- Puzzle at Camp: Choose for the whole journey
The council requires return-load capacity and a separate dry reserve. The Ford cannot carry the return load; the Gully has no dry store; the Ridge offers a sheltered ledge. Which route fits?
Choose one:
- Take the Ridge and use its sheltered ledge.
- Take the Ford because the outward trip is shorter.
- Take the Gully because concealment solves every problem.
Show the hints
- Both constraints must pass, not just one.
- The Ridge is the only option with enough capacity and a dry reserve.
Show the solution
Take the Ridge and use its sheltered ledge. - Puzzle at Camp: Order the expedition
Scout before committing supplies. Establish the dry reserve before advancing to the caves. Return through that reserve after the work is finished. Arrange the four cards.
Put these in the right order:
- Advance to the caves
- Return through the reserve
- Scout the route
- Establish the dry reserve
Show the hints
- The route is checked first; the reserve must exist before the advance.
- Scout → establish reserve → advance → return.
Show the solution
- Scout the route
- Establish the dry reserve
- Advance to the caves
- Return through the reserve
Part 3: Write an abort rule
Choose how to communicate the same clear return rule. The rule is narrative expedition planning; it does not forcibly stop the player’s current combat.
- Talk at Camp with Sir Roderick: A clear reason to return
Roderick says, “If the dry reserve is lost, we return. We do not turn someone else’s courage into permission to ignore the plan. How should I put that in the order?”
Rewards
Show how the quest ends
The council has a route, a reserve and a clear reason to turn back. Roderick is ready to invite you on the expedition; an optional memorial task is also available.